Water Watch NYC

Everything you need to know about water in NYC.

A Brief Overview of the Water Board

1 Comment

The Water Board is one of three governmental bodies responsible for water and sewer in NYC. (The other two are the DEP, which is in charge of system operation and maintenance, and the Municipal Water Finance Authority, which is responsible for debt service.)

The Water Board has three primary oversight functions, all relating to the DEP. These three functions are:

  1. To review and regulate the DEP’s operations and costs.
  2. To set the rates for water and sewer service in New York.
  3. To arbitrate and respond to customer complaints about the DEP.

Now let’s briefly discuss what the Water Board actually does as it relates to these three functions.

  1. The Water Board rarely gives any notice to the DEP’s budget or operations. Recently, they’ve been more concerned with their own budget, which, by the way, is less than 0.001% of the DEP’s budget. The only time they discuss the DEP’s budget and operations is when the DEP asks them for money to fund a project that they don’t want to send out for bidding. Their answer whenever the DEP asks them for money is either to immediately and without deliberation say yes or to put it off until the next meeting, at which time they immediately and without deliberation say yes.
  2. Every year the DEP must determine how much money it needs to operate and how much it needs to charge for water in order to raise that amount of money. They then ask the Water Board to set the water/sewer rate at some number that will help them achieve their goals. The Water Board is meant to examine the DEP’s current and projected expenditures to determine whether or not the rate that the DEP asks for is appropriate. The Water Board never examines; they simply approve, no questions asked. In the rare case that the Water Board does start doing its job, like when members Jim Tripp and Marilyn Gelber started asking tough questions last year, those members find themselves off the Board.
  3. There is an appeals process when one has a DEP billing complaint. Part of that process is to appeal to the DEP Commissioner, Steve Lawitts. If denied, you must later turn to the Water Board, where your complaint is reviewed by the Water Board’s Executive Director, the same Steve Lawitts (Lawitts is also on the Municipal Water Finance Authority) or his Treasurer, William Kusterbeck. To my knowledge, no complaint has ever reached the desk of any Water Board member. How many governmental agencies do you know of that have no third party oversight committees and are instead overseen by the same people making the mistakes in the first place?

Author: Hershel

Hershel is a Water Management Engineer with Ashokan Water Services, where he's actively involved with conservation and building design issues. Prior to his Ashokan, he was with the City of New York. He is a former President of the New York chapter of the American Society of Plumbing Engineers (ASPE) and is a member of AWWA, NYARM and BOMA. Hershel is an avid kayaker.

One thought on “A Brief Overview of the Water Board

  1. This blog’s great!! Thanks🙂.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s